Argosy Book Store
It is a thrill to be able to be writing about the Argosy Bookstore. As a former owner of a children’s book shop, I could not wait to get to 59th Street so that I could delve deeply into this family history, which began in 1925, and share the story of the three extraordinary sisters that have carried on their father’s legacy.
Despite being on 59th Street since the 1930s, the bookstore remains a ‘hidden gem’ to many New Yorkers who will regularly walk by and miss its presence amidst the ever-growing retail buildings. Naomi, one of the sisters, who maintains her post at a desk by the door, says, “About fifteen times a day, I have someone walk in the store, stop in their tracks and say, ‘Oh my goodness, I never knew that this existed.'” And what a wonderful discovery this six-story curiosity is.
Argosy feels as much like a museum as it does a bookstore. With its specialty being rare and out-of-print books, along with a score of historic maps, prints and autographs, it is a treasure trove with a vast selection that has something for everyone. It brought me great pleasure to introduce members of the Manhattan Sideways team to this remarkable shop that I had been scouring for decades. From the moment we walked through their doors, and they commented at the “book smell” that invaded their senses, I knew that I had them hooked. But then their eyes wandered across the shelves of books that dominated the room, catching the paintings hung above them and the green library lamps suspended at every interval, they simply stood in amazement.
And then Naomi greeted us and took us on what would become a remarkable tour of the entire building. We began on the main level, where some of the store’s most beautiful books are showcased, in genres from historical fiction to children’s books. We were amused as Naomi pointed out her special shelves appropriately named “the oh-I-should-have-read-this” – a sort of “un-Barnes and Noble section” that does not necessarily include Hemingway or Faulkner, but certainly exhibits a great awareness and taste in fine literature.
From there, we ventured down to the basement, a general browsing room, and then up to the sixth floor, which Naomi calls the ‘oh my God room,’ as it is filled with autographs from Teddy Roosevelt to Elton John. As one of three sisters who inherited the bookstore from their father, Lou, Naomi explained that each of the siblings maintains an individual pride in a certain collection in the store. For Naomi, it is the autograph collection.
As we continued down, we stopped on a floor dedicated to American History, where there was a fascinating collection of rare books on topics that included American Architecture, the Cold War, and the American Revolution. I was particularly attracted, however, to the map room. As I was wandering through, I discovered an actual first edition map of Manhattan – drawn sideways in 1865.
Argosy Bookstore remains one of the largest, family-run independent bookstores in New York City. Despite impressive offers for its real estate, the store has continued its business through generations and maintains a genuine character matched by only a handful of other businesses in Manhattan.