The story of this sandwich shop and high-end Italian restaurant next door begins with Nicola Marzovilla, born in Puglia, Italy, who moved to New York in 1970. In 1994, he and his wife Dora opened I Trulli after closing down another very successful Italian restaurant, Tempo. The idea behind I Trulli was to showcase authentic food from Southern Italy - including a whole-roasted rabbit, a traditional dish from Puglia - and an all-Italian wine list, one of the few in New York City. Years later, Nicola opened Sottosuolo next door.
Tradition still reigns at I Trulli, a space decorated with Italian frescos, a double-room fireplace, and a brick oven. George Hock, the general manager, told me that he and Nicola personally curate the 450 wines that I Trulli offers (George worked for a winemaker in Sicily for two years) and that Dora makes the pasta everyday. In addition, they try to keep with the "Italian rule" for any dish: no more than three ingredients. So one can be sure that I Trulli and Sottosuolo are as authentic as it gets.