The original story of the Salinas family’s involvement with Subway Inn sounds like a Charles Dickens tale: Marcello Salinas worked as a porter at the bar when it first opened under Charlie Ackerman, ultimately becoming the manger. Apparently his dedication never went unnoticed, and when Mr. Ackerman passed away, Subway Inn was left to Marcello.
Unfortunately, in 2014 the seventy-seven-year-old bar where Joe DiMaggio and Marilyn Monroe used to drink was forced to close after a long battle with the landlords. Along with his son, Steven, Marcello started a petition to save Subway Inn, and while he did not succeed in sparing the bar’s 143 E 60th Street location, in December 2014 they announced that they had found a new home two blocks away.
I was fortunate to catch Steven one day as he was busy getting ready to open at the end of March. We chatted about the move and renovation and how he is going to handle most of the daily operations. When I asked if he was trying to replicate the old Subway Inn exactly, Steven said the answer was yes and no: “This is my dad’s baby. I’m not going to make it look grungy. It wasn’t trashy when Marilyn Monroe came to hang out and it won't be now.” He went on to say that the décor will be the same, down to the original booths and stools, but that he has been scrubbing everything in an effort to give the space a cleaner look. He has also added a bit of a modern touch, in order to keep up with the times. There are a few televisions, but Steven assured me that he does not want to turn Subway Inn into a sports bar. Steven’s specific project has been making the restroom look attractive: he says the new Subway Inn will have “the nicest restroom in New York.” Made out of plywood like the original, rather than sheetrock, he hopes that it will be a lot more welcome than many dive bar bathrooms.
While continuing our conversation, Steven said that everything goes through his father first and that Marcello ultimately makes all the decisions. The whole family has gone through “A lot of heartache, sweat, and tears,” he told me, and so they are looking forward to seeing it all pay off. He realizes that he cannot make everyone happy: he knows some old regulars will not approve of the addition of TVs and new drinks, but Steven believes that if he adheres to the original personality of the bar and his father’s vision, that they will be a success once again.