I wandered into the Madison Square Tavern just a couple months after it had opened in 2015 and knew that I had found something special. Antonio and Deborah, the general manager and bar manager, immediately gave me a warm welcome. Deborah showed me around the massive three-floored space, telling me a bit about the history of the building. Like many places in the neighborhood, it had been home to a furrier before Madison Square Tavern took it over and rebuilt the space from scratch. As I went upstairs with Deborah, she pointed out where high top tables usually stand along the catwalk, when they are not removed for a private event. We then went around the corner to a little nook that Deborah described as “perfect for football parties.” We looked down on the large, open dining room, which was decorated with colorful gourds for the harvest season.
Passing the upstairs bar, Deborah took me back downstairs, noting that the tavern had already amassed a good after-work crowd in its short time being open. The food, which she described as “contemporary American with ethnic influences,” has many gluten-free options. The restaurant is especially known for its pork chop and steaks.
Deborah showed me into another area, a versatile private dining room called “The Den.” Venturing downstairs, I checked out the Cellar Bar, which functions as a small sports bar. Though sports are occasionally shown on the flat screens upstairs, the TVs in the Cellar Bar play the games with sound. It was here that I had the pleasure of meeting Chef Walter Hinds. Before Madison Square Tavern, he had gained a fine reputation working in the Virgin Islands.
Our tour ended at the long Onyx bar, back on the first floor. After getting a taste of each floor, it was clear that there is something here for everyone, whether it be a cozy nook for a private party, a grand dining room for a steak dinner, or a lively sports bar. Madison Square Tavern covers all bases.