This fabulous dessert shop began its life as an ice cream truck, which is no longer in operation. Bowing to popular demand, and only after securing a preferred location on 7th Street, it expanded into a full-fledged shop. Back in 2011, on the first of many visits to The Big Gay Ice Cream Shop, I struck up a conversation with a very enthusiastic patron. I learned that he was a New York firefighter and he told me, “I travel great distances for great food, and this is one of those places.”
Many subsequent visits later, during the summer of 2016, Jessica, an enthusiastic employee, whose vivid pink and purple hair matched the beautiful colors of some of the flavors, proudly informed me that she had sampled every ice cream. This was certainly an impressive feat, considering new flavors are added on a weekly basis - on this particular week it was Blueberry Cobbler. Among the favorites that the Manhattan Sideways team has devoured over the years are the Salty Pimp, a cone of vanilla ice cream, dulce de leche, and sea salt dipped in chocolate, and the Rue McClarahan, bourbon ice cream sandwiched between praline pecan cookies. Jessica confirmed that the Rocky Roadhouse, a chocolate cone with marshmallow fixings, is another popular choice, as are classics like chocolate and vanilla.
The shop encourages customers to be creative and get exactly what they want, allowing them to mix and match unique toppings with several flavors of soft-serve. I strongly recommend combining vanilla with Makers Mark Bourbon Butterscotch and Awesomesauce, a signature spicy chocolate sauce. For those who do not like cream, the splendid La Newyorkina ice pops do the trick.